SEGH Articles

A human health risk assessment framework to improve the management of potentially toxic elements in informally recycled waste electronic and electrical equipment (WEEE)

04 February 2019
Dr Alessandra Cesaro, University of Salerno and Professor Andrew Hursthouse, University of the West of Scotland assess the human health risk of potentially toxic elements in informally recycled waste electronic and electrical equipment (WEEE)

Members of the EU COST Action ES140 ReCreew (http://www.recreew.eu/) have recently completed review studies which provide an assessment of the potential hazard from the informal recycling of WEEE. These activities include manual handling, sorting, component removal, crushing and grinding as well as burning and acid leaching, generate situations around the world where both operators and the wider community are exposed to emissions and residues from these activities. Substances released include a wider range of metallic elements and organic compounds form the component plastics and as a result of heating (burning or melting). Much of the WEEE collected in Europe is destined for third countries and these markets show quite dynamic changes, particularly with recent restrictions on waste import to China. 

The variability of physical and compositional characteristics and rapid growth in WEEE production creates an enormous challenge to establish appropriate methods of handling materials – particularly in the informal sector. ReCreew was concerned that the diverse methods of handling were difficult to assess systematically from a human health risk. Consequently, they embarked on a systematic study of the compositional variation and model processes to see whether there was an opportunity to provide some basis for assessment.

By using knowledge of the compositional features of individual printed circuit boards in WEEE components, an assessment based on theoretical inhalation route, ranked components on their basis of potential harm form a substance weighted perspective. This identified individual groups of components – with the top PCB (printer) nearly 4 times more hazardous than the second place (mobile phone) (Cesaro et al, 2018). Establishing the basis for prioritisation in health protection. Subsequently, a “Shrinking-Core” combustion model was used to look at emissions of metals and organic compounds (dioxins/furans) during open burning practice.  Based on mass weighted toxicity assessment, this clearly identified open burning of cables above computer and mobile phone PCBs (Cesaro et al, 2019).

These early assessments direct research to further develop realistic datasets for compositional variation of WEEE and in producing pragmatic guidance to engage with informal recycling communities and we hope to open the wider debate on resource recovery in the informal sector.


 

Cesaro, A, Belgiorno, V, Vaccari, M, Jandric, A, Chung, TD, Dias, MI, Hursthouse, A & Salhofer, S 2018, 'A device-specific prioritization strategy based on the potential for harm to human health in informal WEEE recycling' Environmental Science and Pollution Research, vol 25, no. 1, pp. 683–692. DOI: 10.1007/s11356-017-0390-7

Cesaro, A, Belgiorno, V, Gorrasi, G, Viscusi, G, Vaccari, M, Vinti, G, Jandric, A, Dias, MI, Hursthouse, A & Salhofer, S 2019, 'A relative risk assessment of the open burning of WEEE' Environmental Science and Pollution Research (accepted, in press).

Keep up to date

Submit Content

Members can keep in touch with their colleagues through short news and events articles of interest to the SEGH community.

Science in the News

Latest on-line papers from the SEGH journal: Environmental Geochemistry and Health

  • Membrane fouling control by Ca 2+ during coagulation–ultrafiltration process for algal-rich water treatment 2019-04-16

    Abstract

    Seasonal algal bloom, a water supply issue worldwide, can be efficiently solved by membrane technology. However, membranes typically suffer from serious fouling, which hinders the wide application of this technology. In this study, the feasibility of adding Ca2+ to control membrane fouling in coagulation–membrane treatment of algal-rich water was investigated. According to the results obtained, the normalized membrane flux decreased by a lower extent upon increasing the concentration of Ca2+ from 0 to 10 mmol/L. Simultaneously, the floc particle size increased significantly with the concentration of Ca2+, which leads to a lower hydraulic resistance. The coagulation performance is also enhanced with the concentration of Ca2+, inducing a slight osmotic pressure-induced resistance. The formation of Ca2+ coagulation flocs resulted in a looser, thin, and permeable cake layer on the membrane surface. This cake layer rejected organic pollutants and could be easily removed by physical and chemical cleaning treatments, as revealed by scanning electron microscopy images. The hydraulic irreversible membrane resistance was significantly reduced upon addition of Ca2+. All these findings suggest that the addition of Ca2+ may provide a simple-operation, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly technology for controlling membrane fouling during coagulation–membrane process for algal-rich water treatment.

  • Evaluation of the raw water quality: physicochemical and toxicological approaches 2019-04-13

    Abstract

    Environmental degradation has increased, mainly as a result of anthropogenic effects arising from population, industrial and agricultural growth. Water pollution is a problem that affects health, safety and welfare of the whole biota which shares the same environment. In Goiânia and metropolitan region, the main water body is the Meia Ponte River that is used for the abstraction of water, disposal of treated wastewater and effluents. In addition, this river receives wastewater from urban and rural areas. The aim in this present study was to evaluate the quality of raw water by some physical, chemical and toxicological tests. The physicochemical results found high levels of turbidity, conductivity, aluminum, phosphorus and metal iron, manganese, copper and lithium when compared to the standards of the Brazilian legislation. The values found of toxicity demonstrated a high degree of cytotoxicity and genotoxicity. Therefore, it was concluded that the Meia Ponte River has been undergoing constant environmental degradation, causing the poor quality of its waters. Thus, measures for the prevention and recovery should be adopted for the maintenance of the Meia Ponte River.

  • Review of the nature of some geophagic materials and their potential health effects on pregnant women: some examples from Africa 2019-04-11

    Abstract

    The voluntary human consumption of soil known as geophagy is a global practice and deep-rooted in many African cultures. The nature of geophagic material varies widely from the types to the composition. Generally, clay and termite mound soils are the main materials consumed by geophagists. Several studies revealed that gestating women across the world consume more soil than other groups for numerous motives. These motivations are related to medicinal, cultural and nutrients supplementation. Although geophagy in pregnancy (GiP) is a universal dynamic habit, the highest prevalence has been reported in African countries such as Kenya, Ghana, Rwanda, Nigeria, Tanzania, and South Africa. Geophagy can be both beneficial and detrimental. Its health effects depend on the amount and composition of the ingested soils, which is subjective to the geology and soil formation processes. In most cases, the negative health effects concomitant with the practice of geophagy eclipse the positive effects. Therefore, knowledge about the nature of geophagic material and the health effects that might arise from their consumption is important.